Mummy Told Me Not to Tell

Mummy Told Me Not to Tell by Cathy Glass
My rating: 2 of 5 stars

I normally really enjoy books by Cathy Glass but this one I couldn't really get into, hence it took me a month to read. There was something that I didn't like about the child that was the main character. Not sure whether it was his behaviour or whether I just didn't like the way Glass portrayed his character. Towards the end you find out very sad news which explains partially why he has such problems and then I felt really bad for him. But the news is also quite disturbing and horrifying so I had my jaw dropped a lot when I was reading what could have contributed to his issues. I also did not like how the social worker, assigned to the case, was so lax about how he dealt with things. Quite often he was under/mis-informed, he rarely met with the children that were under his charge, and he had a not caring attitude towards his job. He was always making excuses for why his actions weren't on time, etc. and the main excuse was that he had just gone through a divorce. Then you find out that he did get an extended leave so he should have been able to collect himself and put his heart and soul into his work upon his return. So yes, I found this book a bit off when compared to the other Cathy Glass books, but they all can't be winners I guess. I will read her books again but I may take a break from them for a while.

View all my reviews

Room

Room by Emma Donoghue
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

This was a fictional story but in this day and age I could definitely see this storyline happening. A woman is held in captivity in a place called ROOM. She never gets to leave and her only source of natural light is from a skylight. Her captor inpregnates her twice but the first child dies in the birthing process. The second child lives and the story is about how she raises her son with the limitations of being contained to one room. The captor comes once a week and brings what the woman and her son call "Sunday Treat(s)". The treats range from birthday presents for the boy to painkillers for the mother. The boy and his mother create an escape plan that on the first try doesn't work but on the second try they are successful. The unfortunate part about the success is that they have been separate from the Outside that the boy is seeing everything for the first time. The only comparisons he can make are with what he has seen on TV which he thinks is a totally different world on its own. I the idea of being introduced to the world and not knowing about certain things or what to expect was very intriguing and Donoghue did a great job in capturing both the son and mother's fear and surprise. In a realistic sense it brought to light what a scary place the world can be. The ending is bittersweet but it kind of leaves the reader hanging. I would have liked to know about how the son and mother were fairing at different times down the road (ie. 5 years, 10 years). I would technically give the story a 3.5 stars but that isn't an option. The book contains a lot of dialogue which should make for a quick read but towards the end I found myself struggling.

View all my reviews